Skip to main content

[C++] enum class

Traditional C++ enum had several issues. To solve these problems, C++11 introduced a new feature called enum class. In this article, I will examine the problems with the traditional enum and how they are solved with enum class.

First, traditional enum could not be forward-declared. The reason was that if the values in the enumerator were unknown, it was impossible to determine their size. However, enum class is treated as int if an underlying type is not specified, assigning values outside the range of an int will raise a compilation error. If you want to use values outside the range of an int, you need to specify the underlying type.

Another problem with traditional enum was that the scope of enumerator names was not limited. Let's see the following example.

Here, we try to represent the results of IO and Parse functions with enums. However, this code will not compile because the Error and Ok of IOResult conflict with those of ParseResult. To resolve this issue, you can change the enumerator names, or use namespaces.

However, with enum class, the names of enumerators are limited to the scope of the enum class, so there is no need for such verbose code.

Most importantly, the biggest problem with traditional enum was that they were weakly typed and could be implicitly converted to integer types. However, enum class do not allow implicit conversion to integer types. If you try to use an enum class as an int, you will encounter a compilation error. You need to use static_cast to explicitly cast it.

As explained above, traditional enum cannot be forward-declared, their enumerator names are not limited in scope, and they can be implicitly converted to integer types. For now, enum class are the correct approach in most case.

Note: This article is a translation of a Korean post written in 2015. If you want to read the original, please refer to this link.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Iterator Adapters in Rust

An Iterator that takes another iterator and returns a new one is called an iterator adapter . The name "adapter" comes from one of the GoF's design patterns, the adapter pattern . However, in reality, it corresponds more to the decorator pattern , so if you pay too much attention to the name, you might get confused about its purpose. So it's better not to worry too much about the name. Enough complaining about the name, what does an iterator adapter do? An iterator adapter adds a task to be performed when the iterator iterates. This will be easier to understand when you see an example. The map function is one of the famous adapters. The iterator returned by the map function for those who have used functional languages iterates over new values transformed from the original values. Besides, various adapters are already implemented in the standard library. Among them, the most frequently used are those that are convenient to use with loops. Examples include the ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Understanding Aspect-Oriented Programming with Python Examples

Object-Oriented Programming (OOP) manages code by grouping it into independent modules known as objects, emphasizing the crucial principle of Separation of Concerns. This means each object should focus on its specific responsibilities. However, real-world applications often feature functionalities that are common across multiple objects or modules, such as logging, security, transaction management, and performance monitoring. These functionalities are called Cross-cutting Concerns. Challenge of Cross-Cutting Concerns Scattering These cross-cutting concerns, when handled solely with OOP, create two major problems. The first problem is Scattering , which is when code for a specific functionality is spread across multiple places through copying and pasting. For instance, imagine adding user permission checks and logging code to every function. The same logging and permission checking code would repeatedly appear within each method. Tangling The other issue is Tangling . This refe...
Post a Comment
Read more